Can a Church Be Charged Under RICO? The Gateway Church & Robert Morris Case Explained

Reports and court filings indicate RICO allegations involving Gateway Church and Robert Morris in ongoing litigation. This article explains what RICO is, how civil and criminal RICO differ, what courts evaluate in these cases, and the practical governance lessons for churches and nonprofits.

Important: Allegations in lawsuits are claims, not findings. Defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.

What Is RICO—in Plain English

RICO stands for Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act. In simple terms, it’s a legal framework that targets the conduct of an enterprise through a pattern of racketeering activity.

• Enterprise: A group or organization—formal or informal—alleged to be used to commit unlawful acts.

• Pattern: At least two qualifying acts within ten years, showing continuity and relationship.

• Racketeering activity (predicate acts): Specific offenses listed in the statute (for example, certain types of fraud or obstruction).

RICO can appear in criminal cases (brought by prosecutors) and civil lawsuits (brought by private parties). In civil RICO, plaintiffs may seek treble damages plus fees if they prove injury caused by a RICO violation.

Criminal vs. Civil RICO

Criminal RICO

• Filed by government prosecutors.

• Potential penalties include imprisonment, fines, and forfeiture.

• Burden of proof is beyond a reasonable doubt.

Civil RICO

• Filed by private plaintiffs.

• Allows recovery of triple damages and attorneys’ fees.

• Burden of proof is preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not).

Why RICO Shows Up in Church/Nonprofit Disputes

Purchase on Amazon

RICO sometimes appears in disputes involving ministries or nonprofits, usually where plaintiffs allege:

• Misuse or misdirection of funds

• Concealment or misrepresentation

• Coordinated activity across individuals or departments

Courts closely examine whether the allegations actually meet the statute’s strict elements, especially enterprise, pattern, and predicate acts. Many claims get narrowed; some proceed past early motions; outcomes vary case by case.

The Gateway Church & Robert Morris Allegations: Big-Picture Context

Public reporting describes RICO allegations involving Gateway Church and Robert Morris in ongoing civil litigation. Separate filings and hearings have been discussed in the media. This article does not attempt to adjudicate any claims; it focuses on explaining the law and the types of questions courts typically address.

Key reminder:

• Allegations are not proof.

• Case posture can change as judges rule on motions, parties amend complaints, or discovery develops.

• Always check the latest docket or official court orders for current status.

What Courts Look For in RICO Cases

When judges evaluate RICO claims—against any organization, religious or otherwise—they typically scrutinize:

1. Specificity of Allegations Are the alleged predicate acts identified with dates, participants, methods, and results?

2. Continuity and Relationship Do the allegations describe an ongoing scheme (not a single dispute) with related acts?

3. Causation and Injury (Civil RICO) Does the complaint plausibly connect the alleged RICO conduct to a concrete, quantifiable injury?

4. Plausibility Under the Statute

5. Even if behavior seems problematic, does it satisfy RICO’s precise elements, or is another law (e.g., contract or fraud) more appropriate?

Practical Takeaways for Churches & Nonprofits

Regardless of how any particular case ends, allegations alone can erode trust. Strong governance reduces risk and builds resilience:

1) Board Oversight & Minutes

• Keep detailed minutes reflecting questions, debate, and final votes.

• Require dashboards for finance, compliance, and risk at each meeting.

2) Financial Controls & Transparency

• Separate restricted vs. unrestricted funds and document their use.

• Require dual sign-offs for large disbursements and vendor changes.

• Conduct periodic external audits and publish summaries for donors.

3) Policies That Actually Work

• Whistleblower policy: Anonymous hotline, anti-retaliation language, independent review path.

• Conflict of interest: Annual disclosures, recusals, and independent oversight of related-party transactions.

• Document retention: Clear rules for preserving emails, messages, and records during audits or litigation holds.

4) Communications & Crisis Readiness

• Prepare pre-approved statements and Q&A for members and donors.

• Identify a single spokesperson and a legal review step before public statements.

• Create a media protocol: who monitors coverage, who drafts updates, how quickly you respond.

5) Training & Culture

• Train leaders and staff on restricted gifts, expense policies, and reporting concerns.

• Reinforce an ethos of stewardship, openness, and member/donor respect.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this a criminal case? RICO can be criminal or civil. Media coverage around Gateway Church and Robert Morris has focused on civil allegations in litigation contexts. The exact posture depends on active filings and court rulings at any given time.

Does RICO only apply to the Mafia? No. While RICO was crafted to address organized crime, it applies wherever the statute’s elements are met—businesses, nonprofits, or other groups.

What outcomes are possible in civil RICO suits? Outcomes range from dismissal, to partial dismissal with amendments, to settlement, or trial. Many cases narrow significantly as courts analyze the statutory elements.

If a church faces RICO allegations, what should leaders do first? Consult qualified legal counsel, initiate a document preservation hold, review and tighten financial controls, and establish clear communications to members and donors.

Final Thoughts

RICO is powerful—and complicated. When it surfaces in a church context, it raises sensitive questions about governance, stewardship, and accountability. Regardless of the legal outcome, ministries protect their mission by embracing clear policies, transparent finances, and rigorous oversight.

Editorial & Legal Disclaimer

This article is news commentary and general legal education. It is not legal advice. All defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. Facts may evolve as courts rule and new filings appear. For advice on a specific situation, consult a licensed attorney.